Chapter One
America Bashers
Why do so many americans who ought to know better find the United States
such a terrible place?
Maybe “terrible” isn’t exactly the right word, but it’s pretty close. So
are “corrupt” and “immoral” and “dishonorable” and a whole bunch of other
words just like those. America never quite seems to get it right, as far
as these people are concerned. If something bad happens someplace in the
world, it’s got to be our fault. And not just because our plans went bad,
but because our motives were all wrong. Day in and day out, in their eyes,
America comes up short. This country, as far as they’re concerned, is a
never-ending source of embarrassment. They just don’t trust America to do
the right thing – because, to them, this is a land of bottomless
stupidity and eternal sin.
Whom exactly are we talking about? Unfortunately, not just drugged-out
revolutionaries on the fringe, the kind of people we could simply write
off as crackpots. And not mainly college kids, either, which would at
least be a kind of excuse. No, the America Bashers these days are in the
mainstream, in the top ranks of the nation’s intelligentsia and cultural
elite – professors at some of our top schools, journalists at some of our
most important news organizations, celebrities in Hollywood, and, of
course, Michael Moore, the reigning king of America Bashers, who deserves
a category all his own.
Moore once told a British newspaper that the United States is a country
that “is known for bringing sadness and misery to places around the
globe.” And just hours after the attacks of September 11, he posted this
lovely message on his Web site: “Many families have been devastated
tonight,” he wrote. “This just is not right. They did not deserve to die.
If someone did this to get back at Bush, then they did so by killing
thousands of people who DID NOT VOTE for him! Boston, New York, DC, and
the planes’ destination of California – these were places that voted
AGAINST Bush!”
Can you imagine if Rush Limbaugh had said something like this? Not even
the lunatic fringe would have embraced him. But Michael Moore says
something this dumb and it doesn’t even register with the cultural elite
as over the line, let alone flat-out disgusting. To the contrary – or au
contraire, as they say in France where Michael Moore is even bigger than
Jerry Lewis – liberals continue to celebrate him as a national treasure,
as a courageous voice of sanity. When his documentary, Fahrenheit 9/11,
premiered in Washington, he invited to the gala some of the city’s most
elite Democrats, who applauded enthusiastically throughout the movie,
then, when it was over, gave him a standing ovation. Make no mistake:
Michael Moore isn’t the court jester. He’s not a Yippie like Abbie Hoffman
in 1968. Millions of mainstream liberals who once looked up to JFK are now
idolizing this guy!
And the fact that so many America Bashers are middle-aged, like Michael
Moore, helps explain where they’re coming from, to use that old phrase.
They are of a generation – or, more precisely, they are of a part of a
generation – that long ago defined itself by its skepticism about
everything America is and everything America does. Most of these people
came of age during Vietnam, and in some important ways, they’ve never
moved beyond one of the core beliefs of those days: that America is a
bully, that it is an oppressor, and that standing up and saying so
automatically defines you as a decent and moral person – no matter how
you behave in the rest of your life.
With that in mind, consider the reaction of such people to the abuses at
the Abu Ghraib prison in Iraq. Decent Americans, of course, were offended
by the revelations of what went on there. But was it a horror comparable
to the 1968 My Lai Massacre in Vietnam, where hundreds of unarmed men,
women, children, and old people were taken out and slaughtered in cold
blood by American troops?
The very question is obscene.
But not to the America Bashers, including many in the mainstream press. To
them, what happened at Abu Ghraib was less a tragedy than an opportunity
– one more chance to reveal America as depraved and dishonorable.
Take Frank Rich and Paul Krugman, two of the most popular liberal pundits
at the New York Times.
If you read Rich on Abu Ghraib, you sense his thrill at the chance to
relive glory days gone by, when he and his pals were running around the
Harvard campus playing at revolution. “It was in November 1969,” he wrote
in his May 9, 2004, column, “that a little-known reporter, Seymour Hersh,
broke the story of the 1968 massacre at My Lai, the horrific scoop that
has now found its match 35 years later in Mr. Hersh’s New Yorker
revelation of a 53- page Army report detailing ‘numerous instances of
sadistic, blatant and wanton criminal abuse’ at Abu Ghraib.”
If Frank Rich were as stupid as he seems to think most Americans are, such
an absurd exaggeration might be understandable, if not excusable. But,
much as he may lack common sense, he is not stupid. What he is (aside from
snide and vicious) is deeply committed to a false vision of America and
its people. It’s exactly the way alienated rich kids (like Frank Rich)
used to write for their college papers back in the 60s. The difference is,
now they do it in the pages of the New York Times.
Or take Paul Krugman, the most ideologically left-wing columnist on the
Times’ op-ed page, which is no small feat. On May 11, two days after the
Frank Rich column, Krugman hopped on the My Lai express with this
brilliant observation: “Seymour Hersh is exposing My Lai all over again.”
For Paul Krugman, and for many of his devoted readers who eagerly embrace
his warped view of America and its military, this blatant absurdity had
become a simple fact. It was, after all, in the New York Times. What more
does anybody need?
(Continues…)
HarperCollins
ISBN: 0-06-076128-8
Excerpted from 100 People Who Are Screwing Up America (and Al Franken Is #37)
by Bernard Goldberg Excerpted by permission.
All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.
Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site.
