x-Goose Gossage 466 (85.8 percent), Jim Rice 392 (72.2), Andre Dawson 358 (65.9), Bert Blyleven 336 (61.9), Lee Smith 235 (43.3), Jack Morris 233 (42.9), Tommy John 158 (29.1), Tim Raines 132 (24.3), Mark McGwire 128 (23.6), Alan Trammell 99 (18.2), y-Dave Concepcion 88 (16.2), Don Mattingly 86 (15.8), Dave Parker 82 (15.1), Dale Murphy 75 (13.8), Harold Baines 28 (5.2).
By receiving fewer than 27 votes (less than 5 percent), Rod Beck 2 (0.4), Travis Fryman 2 (0.4), Robb Nen 2 (0.4), Shawon Dunston 1 (0.2), Chuck Finley 1 (0.2), David Justice 1 (0.2), Chuck Knoblauch 1 (0.2), Todd Stottlemyre 1 (0.2), Brady Anderson 0 and Jose Rijo 0 are no longer eligible for election by the BBWAA.
x-elected
y-final year of eligibility for election by the BBWAA
