ap

Skip to content
Denver Post sports columnist Troy Renck photographed at studio of Denver Post in Denver on Tuesday, Feb. 20, 2024. (Photo by Hyoung Chang/The Denver Post)
PUBLISHED: | UPDATED:
Getting your player ready...

Geno Smith is everything Peyton Manning is not. The New York Jets embattled quarterback spent this week answering questions about whether he could tell time, if he liked movies more than game film, and if he expected home fans to turn on him after a expletive-filled exchange with a paying customer.

Smith is the Jets’ problem. He is also an NFL problem, the latest in a long list of highly drafted quarterbacks who deployed air bags a few intersections into their careers.

In an age of sport-specific training and youth specialization, it remains startling that the NFL can’t produce 20 good quarterbacks. The annual rate of failure reaffirms that is the league’s toughest position, if not the hardest in sports.

For every conversation about Manning, Andrew Luck and Aaron Rodgers, there’s a Dead Sea Scrolls list of failed high-round prospects.

“If it was that easy, there would be a lot more guys we would be talking about,” Broncos offensive coordinator Adam Gase said. “Instead of the top five, you’d say here’s the top 15. You don’t even say that. There are three to four guys that people talk about and every week go, ‘This is going to be a tough matchup.’ Then past that I’m sure there are a lot of defenses that just say we’re better than what the quarterback is going to bring.”

The Jets host the Broncos on Sunday, reeling from poor play from Smith. He is tied for the league lead in interceptions (six) and turnovers (eight).

Jets coach Rex Ryan supports Smith, if for no other reason than Michael Vick played similarly awful in the second half last week.

“I hope that he’s out there every snap and doing well,” Ryan said. “I don’t think in negative terms.”

Smith, 23, apologized to teammates for missing a meeting before the 31-0 loss to the San Diego Chargers, saying the time change created confusion. He flashes athleticism worthy of his second-round status but makes maddening mistakes.

It’s easy to forget he’s played in only 21 games. Patience is a dirty word in today’s NFL, a leading factor in the early mortality rate of quarterback careers. Owners want winners. When they allocate a huge chunk of the salary cap to a quarterback, they don’t want him to redshirt.

Good enough to draft high, good enough to play early. It sounds great to the fan base, but rarely ends well. Two quarterbacks drafted in the first round over the past 10 years — Rodgers and Joe Flacco — have won a Super Bowl. Six are out of the league, including Tim Tebow, JaMarcus Russell, Matt Leinart and Vince Young.

Twenty years ago, quarterbacks were viewed as developmental projects. Time is no longer their friend, the stories of Rodgers and Steve McNair learning as backups as common as cassette tapes.

A high-round pick must gain traction early, and usually with a bad team. The Colts’ Luck has pulled it off. Russell Wilson, a third-round pick, won a job as a rookie and a championship last season, but joined a contending team.

Smith’s play provides a juxtaposition. His numbers have been deplorable by any statistical measure. He doesn’t possess many weapons — receiver Eric Decker is expected to return from injury Sunday — leaving Ryan to blurt after last week’s loss in San Diego, “We could’ve had Joe Namath, and it wouldn’t have mattered.”

The challenge for quarterbacks is real. Thumb through the bios, and the issues aren’t physical. Quarterbacks run 6-foot-3 to 6-5, and weigh approximately 230 pounds. The software is more important than the hardware.

The ability to process information quickly is the great separator. Manning can sit in the shotgun, run the play clock down to six seconds and make an adjustment. For young quarterbacks, everything happens fast.

“The defenses make it hard. We can give them so many disguises, and unless you have been in the league for as long as Peyton, it’s difficult to break that down, especially a guy like Geno,” Broncos cornerback Chris Harris said.

There’s no iPhone app for audibles, no Siri to provide answers for a zone coverage blitz.

Manning threw a rookie-record 28 interceptions — in 576 attempts — before beginning his Hall of Fame pursuit in his sophomore season. He cautions that playing quarterback is a marathon, not a sprint. Too many never make it out of the starting blocks.

“I didn’t play particularly well in a number of games, and I’m not sure we were just loaded with talent. I don’t want to offend anybody on that 3-13 team, but looking back I can remember just realizing how hard it was to win,” Manning said, before adding, “I think it depends on the situation and kind of how the games are going, but I think it just shows how hard it is.”

Troy E. Renck: trenck@denverpost.com or


QB or not QB, that is the question

Playing quarterback remains one of the toughest jobs in sports. Finding the right one is an inexact science. NFL reporter Troy E. Renck looks at the first-round quarterbacks drafted over the past five years and how they’ve fared:

tr {
font-size: small;
}

QB Year Pick Team Comp. Att. TDs Int. Rating Comment
Blake Bortles 2014 3 Jaguars 65 97 3 6 71.0 Will early playing time stunt growth?
Johnny Manziel 2014 22 Browns 0 1 0 0 39.6 Maturity issues continue to follow him.
Teddy Bridgewater 2014 32 Vikings 31 50 0 0 92.7 Acts, looks part of franchise QB.
E.J. Manuel 2013 16 Bills 256 437 16 12 80.3 Benched last week in favor of Kyle Orton.
Andrew Luck 2012 1 Colts 829 1,413 60 33 84.3 Close to entering pantheon of league’s elite.
Robert Griffin III 2012 2 Redskins 563 889 36 17 91.8 Marred by knee injuries since rookie year.
Ryan Tannehill 2012 8 Dolphins 372 620 24 12 81.2 Job security dwindling by the week.
Brandon Weeden 2012 22 Browns 438 784 23 26 71.8 Underwhelming backup with Cowboys.
Cam Newton 2011 1 Panthers 961 1,604 69 43 87.1 Pro Bowler who continues to improve.
Jake Locker 2011 8 Titans 387 675 26 19 80.2 Injury prone and largely ineffective.
Blaine Gabbert 2011 10 Jaguars 414 777 22 24 66.4 Complete bust, traded to 49ers.
Christian Ponder 2011 12 Vikings 632 1,057 38 36 75.9 A third-stringer used in emergency only.
Sam Bradford 2010 1 Rams 1,032 1,760 59 38 79.3 Blown-out knee in back-to-back seasons.
Tim Tebow 2010 25 Broncos 173 361 17 9 75.3 Out of league, working for ESPN.

RevContent Feed

More in Sports