Troy Renck: Nikola Jokic plays with endless imagination. Nathan MacKinnon boasts gifted athleticism. From the moment Jokic became an All-Star with his propensity for triple doubles, from the first time MacKinnon barreled down the ice like his skates were attached to a V-8, winning a championship seemed like a given. Both delivered — Jokic’s carried more weight since it was the Nuggets’ first — but after another empty postseason, it is fair to pose a sobering question: will either win another one?
Sean Keeler: Cale Makar turned 27 last October. No title window is officially closed on the Avs until Makar is either closer to 37 or 38 or no longer wearing burgundy and blue. Between Jokic and MacKinnon, you lean with Nate Dogg, if only because the Stanley Cup Playoffs are far more random than the NBA counterpart; because Cale is so young; and because the Nuggets’ path in the West now has more potholes than Monaco Street Parkway. The Wemby Era is officially upon us, my friend. Only it’s also coming at the apex of The SGA Era, which means there’s not enough room on the medal stand for everybody.
Renck: The answer is MacKinnon. He will have more legit chances than Jokic, even after the Avs wasted a prime opportunity last week against Las Vegas. No matter whether the Avs keep coach Jared Bednar or not, they will remain a contender for the next five seasons with MacKinnon and Makar. But the onus is on the 30-year-old MacKinnon to adapt to new tactics, to show he can lead a team to a title against opponents who control the middle of the ice. If the Avs remain stubborn and play a style that suits their stars in the regular season, MacKinnon might win another title, but will be at the end of his career with another team.
Keeler: After Nuggets-Timberwolves I (2024), I wondered if Jokic’s best chance for a second title might happen as a veteran big man off the bench for another franchise — think the Lakers’ version of Dwight Howard or the Celtics’ version of Bill Walton. Not anymore. I think the Joker is going to play out this next, massive contract extension, and try like holy heck to finish what he started here. And then that’ll be it — ring or no ring, it’s back to Sombor, to the horses, to family, and to the next chapters of his life.
Renck: Jokic, 31, cannot be considered a Top 10 all-time great without another ring, finishing in the rankings in the second tier a tick ahead of Moses Malone, Dirk Nowitzki, Giannis Antetokounmpo. Given how the NBA works and how the collective bargaining agreement is structured, teams don’t get title shots every season since owners view the aprons as hard caps. After capitulating against the Timberwolves, the Nuggets must take a step back, trade away Cam Johnson and Aaron Gordon, and load up for a three-year run in Jokic’s final sprint starting in 2029. Even then, there is a 7-foot-5 problem. Victor Wembanyama is now the face of the league (and everyone’s favorite player after eliminating the Oklahoma City Floppers). At 22 years old, Wembanyama is the youngest player to lead his team in points per game and rebounds in a season when his team makes the NBA Finals. He is not going anywhere. For Jokic to win, it will likely require a much different, more athletic supporting cast. MacKinnon, if he shows adaptability, probably only needs a different coach.
Keeler: Just because “everything” is on the table for Josh Kroenke doesn’t mean KSE is comfortable ordering the most expensive menu items in front of them. The greatest speed bump lodged between two of Denver’s all-time greats and a second ring might be the entity that owns them both. With the Nuggets, the Kroenkes are reluctant to splash serious cash to upgrade the coaching staff or the front office and reportedly unwilling to eat more luxury tax penalties. With the Avs, Stan and Josh seem content to know what they don’t know and let Joe Sakic run that branch of the family business. In both cases, the longer KSE remains resistant to change, the shorter Jokic’s and MacKinnon’s title windows become.
